Is it worth grading Magearna #XY186 from XY Black Star Promos?

It depends on condition and market pricing. Current PSA 10 gem rate is 24.7% (based on 745 graded copies). PSA 10 sales average $3499.35 versus a raw market of $29.99. Use the calculator on this page to compute exact EV for your card's condition.

What is the PSA 10 gem rate for Magearna #XY186?

24.7% (based on 745 graded copies)

What does PSA grading cost?

PSA service levels range from $59.99 per card (Standard, 90-100 business days) to $9,999+ (Premium 10, for cards worth $250,001+). If a graded card is worth more than its tier's Max Insured Value, PSA upgrades it to the tier that covers it and bills the difference.

Should You Grade Magearna #XY186 (XY Black Star Promos)? PSA Grading EV

← All cards · Grade It

Should You Grade Magearna?

XY Black Star Promos · #XY186 · Promo

Default-tier verdict

Grade It+$551 (+142% ROI)

Based on raw market $29.99, PSA 10 $3499.35, gem rate 24.7% (745 graded). Adjust inputs below for your card's exact condition.

Magearna

XY Black Star Promos · #XY186 · Promo

Market: $29.99

View card page

PSA Pop · 745 graded

PSA 10

24.7%

PSA 9

42.8%

PSA 8

18.4%

PSA 7

10.3%

Your Costs

Raw card cost

Grading tier

Shipping estimate + Other fees

Expected Sale Prices

PSA 10

PSA 9

PSA 8

PSA 7

Card Condition

Centering

Edges & Corners

Surface

Fine-tune your gem-rate odds based on centering, edges, and surface condition.

Expected Value

⚠If graded PSA 10, PSA will upcharge to Super Express ($349) — your PSA 10 value of $3499 exceeds this tier's $1,000 cap. No upcharge on PSA 9.

PSA 10: 24.7% × $3499.35+$864.27

PSA 9: 42.8% × $146.56+$62.76

PSA 8: 18.4% × $51.98+$9.56

PSA 7: 10.3% × $22.49+$2.32

Below 7: 3.8% × raw+$1.13

Raw card cost-$29.99

Standard grading (weighted avg)-$131.37

Shipping + Other Fees-$10.00

EV+$768.67(+449% ROI)

Grade It

449% ROI — strong margin absorbs selling fees and price swings.

Want to track this card's price and grading data?

Grade It

449% ROI — strong margin absorbs selling fees and price swings.

About this calculator

This page computes the expected value (EV) of submitting Magearna #XY186 to PSA for grading. EV factors in real PSA population data (gem rates), live market prices for raw and graded copies, and PSA's tiered fee structure including upcharges when a card's graded value exceeds the tier's Max Insured Value. Adjust the inputs to match your card's exact condition for a personalized recommendation.

PSA population summary

Grade	Population	Rate
PSA 10	184	24.7%
PSA 9	319	42.8%
PSA 8	137	18.4%
PSA 7	77	10.3%

Should You Grade Magearna #XY186 from XY Black Star Promos?

Magearna

Your Costs

Expected Sale Prices

Card Condition

Expected Value

About this calculator

PSA population summary

Magearna

Your Costs

Expected Sale Prices

Card Condition

Expected Value